There have been dozens of memorable Sunday night dinner scenes on “Blue Bloods” over the years. Whether it’s Jamie and Eddie (Vanessa Ray) announcing their engagement, or Nicky (Sami Gayle) distracting the family from an argument by revealing she has a tattoo, the dinners are unpredictable launching pads for new plot twists, resolutions, and wild family discussions.

When Looper surveyed fans of the drama to find out which Sunday family dinner moments were their favorite, most of them picked out the sweet, but happily uneventful one from Season 1’s “To Tell The Truth.” The scene sees Linda Reagan (Amy Carlson) finally return home after being held hostage in a kidnapping situation. 

Both Donnie Walhberg and Tom Selleck have also named the most memorable Reagan family meals for them, with Wahlberg telling CinemaBlend that the very first meal remains his favorite. Meanwhile, Selleck told TV Insider that his favorite is Season 2’s “The Job,” where Frank reveals he survived the 9/11 attacks. 

Whether you like it when the Reagans fight or whether you like them working, whenever they meet to eat, there’s always something for them to chew over.