Over on X (formerly known as Twitter), some fans put Macy Gray’s name out there when Robin Thicke admitted he couldn’t figure out the Sea Queen’s identity. “I like Kenny’s guess, but it sounds like Macy Gray to me,” @epjeanne wrote, presumably referring to Ken Jeong. User @mattyxlp added some more evidence: “That’s Macy Gray! She was on Aus version of the show last year.” From there, a bunch of other users went on to name Gray, so she’s definitely a popular guess.

Anyone who’s listened to Gray before knows that she has an incredibly distinctive, raspy voice — and based on the Sea Queen’s performance of “Love Potion No. 9,” it definitely sounds like Gray could be hiding under that mask. The singer’s most recent album was way back in 2018, so if she’s looking to boost her image before heading out on a new tour, it could be Gray, even though she might not be as well known for any comedic chops. After being marked safe in Episode 5, though, it’s possible fans will have to wait a little while before they learn if their guesses are correct.

“The Masked Singer” airs on Wednesdays on Fox.