Did Mattie Pruitt’s Mom Sara Lyle Audition for American Idol While Pregnant? Find Out More

Mattie Pruitt, a remarkable contestant on American Idol Season 23, recently opened up about a touching story involving her mother, Sara Lyle.

Sara had auditioned for American Idol while she was pregnant with Mattie.

This revelation adds a special dimension to Mattie’s own journey on the show, showcasing a family history filled with a love for music and a strong sense of determination.

Did Mattie Pruitt’s Mom Sara Lyle Audition for American Idol While Pregnant?

During rehearsals for the American Idol 2025 performances in Hawaii, Mattie was surprised by her mom, Sara. Sara shared that she had auditioned for American Idol when she was pregnant with Mattie, likely during Seasons 10 or 11.

This unique connection between mother and daughter emphasizes how music and the dream of performing have been woven into Mattie’s life from the very start.

Mattie’s Rise on American Idol

Born in 2009 and raised in Eagleville, Tennessee, Mattie has been singing since she was little. With encouragement from her parents, she started posting singing videos on social media in 2023 and quickly drew attention for her talent.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Mattie Pruitt (@mattiepruittofficial)

Her audition for American Idol in March 2025, where she performed Jessie Murph’s “How Could You,” impressed both the judges and the audience. Carrie Underwood, one of the judges, praised Mattie’s beautiful voice, noting her shyness. Ultimately, she became the youngest contestant in the top 12 of Season 23.

Memorable Performances and Judges’ Praise

Mattie’s performances on the show have been defined by their emotional depth and vocal sophistication. A standout moment was her rendition of Katy Perry’s “Wide Awake,” which truly captivated Carrie Underwood.

Underwood remarked on how Mattie put her own spin on the classic song, calling it a fresh and mesmerizing interpretation. Lionel Richie also commended the distinctive “growl” in Mattie’s voice, recognizing her as a unique artist.

The Impact of Sara Lyle’s Audition Story

Sara Lyle’s experience auditioning while pregnant with Mattie adds a powerful narrative of perseverance and passion to Mattie’s story. It highlights that Mattie’s musical journey is not just about her own talent and dedication but also shaped by her mother’s early dreams.

This generational connection enhances Mattie’s rise on American Idol and resonates with fans who value the deeper family ties behind the success of artists.